• Year 2007 – Teen Choice Award – Choice TV Actor Drama for Prison Break
• Year 2006 – Saturn Award – Best Actor on Television for Prison Break
• Year 2006 – Golden Globe – Best Performance by an Actor in a Television Series – Drama for Prison Break
• Year 2006 – Teen Choice Award – TV – Choice Actor for Prison Break
• Year 2006 – Teen Choice Award – TV – Choice Breakout Star for Prison Break
• Year 2004 – Black Reel Awards – Best Actor for The Human Stain
• Year 2004 – Black Reel Awards – Best Breakthrough Performance for The Human Stain